Type I and Type II Elastic Rail Clips: Differences in Toe Load and Application

Jan 22, 2024 Leave a message

How an Elastic Rail Clip Holds the Track

An elastic rail clip works by bending. The clip is anchored against a shoulder on the sleeper or baseplate, and its curved leg presses down on the rail foot through an insulator. The downward force is called toe load, and it is what produces the friction that stops the rail walking longitudinally and what keeps the rail from tilting or lifting under traffic. Toe load varies with the type of clip, the wire or bar diameter, the free height after forming, and the stiffness of the pad under the rail foot.

Type I and Type II clips are the two classic wire clip designs used with timber and concrete sleepers. The naming follows the clamping duty rather than any single standard, so it is worth comparing the two designs on load, elastic range and the rail sections they normally serve.

Type I Clip Characteristics

Type I clips are the lighter of the two designs. Their clamping force is comparatively low and their elastic range is small, which means the clip has less reserve to compensate for sleeper hole wear, pad creep or rail foot wear over time. They are generally installed on 50 kg/m rail sections, such as the 50 kg/m profile defined in GB/T 2585 and comparable 100 lb per yard sections. On secondary lines with moderate axle loads Type I clips perform adequately, but they are not the first choice where heavy haul traffic, tight curves or high-speed running demand sustained and repeatable restraint.

Type II Clip Characteristics

Type II clips use a heavier section and a visibly larger wire diameter, in the region of 10 mm and above for the standard designs. The larger section gives a higher toe load and a much wider elastic range, so the clip continues to press on the rail foot even after the assembly has settled or the sleeper hole has enlarged. Type II clips are normally used with 60 kg/m rail, including the 60E1 profile of EN 13674-1 and 60 kg/m sections to GB/T 2585, and they are the default choice for heavy haul corridors and high-speed lines built on concrete sleepers.

Comparison at a Glance

Characteristic Type I elastic clip Type II elastic clip
Clamping force (toe load) Lower, limited reserve Higher, sustained
Elastic range Smaller Larger
Bar or wire diameter Smaller section Approximately 10 mm and above
Typical rail section 50 kg/m 60 kg/m, including 60E1
Usual application Secondary lines, moderate axle load Heavy haul, high speed, curves

The practical selection rule is that the clip must still deliver adequate toe load at the end of its service interval, after pad set and hole wear have been taken into account, not merely at the moment of installation.

Material and Heat Treatment

Wire clips for track are made from silicon-manganese spring steel, typically grade 60Si2MnA to GB/T 1222, which combines high elastic limit with enough ductility to survive forming. The steel is austenitised, quenched and tempered to develop the required elastic properties, then the clip is cold formed and set so that it takes a permanent deformation at installation instead of losing toe load. Spring steel strip and bar for springs is also specified through EN 10089 where quenched and tempered spring steels are called up. Cleanliness and surface condition matter, because a surface defect at the bend radius becomes a fatigue initiation site.

Fatigue, Testing and Field Behaviour

A clip in track is loaded every time a wheel passes, so it sees millions of load cycles plus corrosion and occasional impact. Two tests dominate acceptance: a repeated load test that demonstrates the clip keeps a defined toe load and does not crack after a large number of cycles, and a corrosion test that shows the coating survives the environment. Fastening systems are assessed as complete assemblies using the performance requirements of EN 13481-1 and EN 13481-2 together with the test methods of the EN 13146 series, which include clamping force measurement and electrical resistance of the assembly.

In service the two most common complaints are loss of toe load and clip breakage. Loss of toe load usually traces back to pad compression set, worn insulators or enlarged shoulders rather than to the clip itself. Breakage is normally a fatigue crack starting at a forming mark or a galvanising defect at the bend. Field inspection should therefore record visible cracking, permanent set relative to a reference gauge, insulator condition and pad thickness.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What is the main difference between Type I and Type II elastic rail clips?
A: Type I clips provide a lower clamping force and a smaller elastic range and are used mainly on 50 kg/m rail, while Type II clips provide higher toe load and a wider elastic range, with bar diameters of roughly 10 mm and above, and are used on 60 kg/m rail.

Q: Which rail sections suit a Type II clip?
A: The stiffest and most common application is 60 kg/m rail, including the 60E1 profile of EN 13674-1 and 60 kg/m sections to GB/T 2585, particularly on heavy haul and high-speed lines.

Q: Why does toe load fall over time?
A: Mainly because the rail pad takes a compression set, the insulator wears and the sleeper hole or shoulder enlarges. The clip itself usually retains most of its elasticity if it has been correctly set during manufacture.

Q: What material are elastic clips made from?
A: Silicon-manganese spring steel such as 60Si2MnA to GB/T 1222, formed and heat treated to develop the required elastic limit, and where spring steel bar is purchased it is commonly ordered to EN 10089.

Q: How is a fastening system tested as an assembly?
A: Through the performance requirements of EN 13481-1 and EN 13481-2 combined with the EN 13146 test methods, covering clamping force, longitudinal restraint, electrical resistance and repeated load behaviour.

Q: Can Type I and Type II clips be mixed in one track?
A: They can be installed on different rail sections in the same project, but mixing them within one fastening assembly is avoided because the toe load and thus the restraint on that sleeper would differ from its neighbours.